Transvox - The Cass Report - Our thoughts....

Gillian and Jenny discuss the report by Dr. Hilary Cass on gender identity services for young people at the Tavistock. They both express concerns about the report's recommendations and the language used, which they agree is potentially misleading. They also discuss the ongoing debates surrounding trans rights and the toxicity from groups opposing trans people. They are particularly concerned about the strategic framing of the issue of puberty blockers for young people, suggesting it could be a Trojan horse for future legislation.

They refute the report's claims, stating that being trans is not a mental illness and whilst there can be a correlation between trans identity and neurodivergence one does not cause the other.  Gillian pointed out that treating trans people had positive affects and that something like 50-100 research papers had been ignored to produce the Cass report. Gillian argued that the current research approach is reminiscent of tobacco companies sponsoring positive research on the effects of cancer on cigarettes.

They suggest that the best way to effect change is through contacting MPs, as political pressure was the only avenue for influencing decision-makers. Jenny expressd frustration about the hostile environment created by extreme views within their community but remains hopeful about the resilience of their community and the potential support from allies and young people.

Gillian suggests that the Labour Party, given their current position, could be more open to positive changes for the trans community. Jenny agrees, highlighting her own experiences with supportive MPs within the Labour Party. They also note the growing focus on anti-trans messaging within the Conservative Party and the potential negative impact on their polling.

They also discus the challenges faced by trans individuals, particularly in terms of visibility and acceptance. They emphasise the need for continued advocacy and pushing back against misinformation and prejudice.

They acknowledge the ongoing struggles against prejudice and bullying, particularly in the UK and America, but express hope in the younger generations' acceptance and support. They also are hopeful about the need for continued advocacy and support for causes such as gender and disability rights. Both agreed to maintain a positive outlook and continue to support each other through these challenging times as should we all.

Hope you enjoy and find this useful.

You can donate to support the work on the podcast or to help build the ‘hardship fund’ at @BeyondReflections - to help those who are financially challenged but still need support

You can submit questions to gillianrussell77@yahoo.com